Melania Trump Likely Would’ve Been Prioritized For Deportation Under Trump’s Policies in the ‘90s
One of Donald Trump’s immigration-related executive orders include one from Jan. 25, right after he became president, in which he said there would be a prioritization of the deportation of people who “engaged in fraud or willful misrepresentation in connection with any official matter or application before a governmental agency.”
And now, under this executive order, the First Lady herself would have been prioritized for deportation had Trump been president when she was in the United States in the ‘90s with a B1/B2 visitor visa.
That’s because Melania Trump — whose last name was Knauss or Knavs in 1996 — did modeling work that she was paid for, according to the Associated Press, which would have been a violation of her visa terms.
“If the current executive order on interior enforcement and the related Homeland Security memoranda on interior enforcement had been in effect at that time, then she would have certainly been an enforcement priority,” Hasan Shafiqullah, the deputy attorney in charge of the immigration law unit at the Legal Aid Society, told Slate.
New York City immigration specialist Cheryl David agreed.
She said that if Melania Trump did in fact undertake paid work while in the United States a tourist visa, she “definitely violated her status, and if it came to immigration’s attention, yeah, they certainly could put her into removal proceedings”.
In theory, Melania Trump’s citizenship could still be revoked on the grounds that she willfully misrepresented or concealed facts relevant to her naturalization.
Historically, this has only been done in extreme cases, with terrorists and war criminals among those targeted.
But Donald Trump has ordered the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to actively target and deport people who were technically violating the rules, insisting that if immigrants violate US law in any way, “they have to go”.
These include those whose indiscretions were considered too minor to act on by Barack Obama and other presidents before him.
Back when he was merely a presidential candidate, Donald Trump promised that he would give a press conference “in a few weeks” about wife Melania Trump’s immigration history.
That was in June 2016.
Trump is now president, and the American people never got that press conference that we were promised.
While on the 2016 campaign trail, Trump said Melania came into the country legally.
“She has got it so documented,” Trump said, adding they would hold a news conference in a few weeks to address the issue.
“They said, ‘Melania Trump may have come into our country illegally’ and ‘how would that be for Donald Trump?'” Trump said of the media after questions arose about when and how Melania Trump received her green card.
“Here’s the only problem, she came in totally legally,” he continued.
“I said to her: ‘No no, let it simmer for a little while. Let them go wild, let it simmer, and then let’s have a little news conference.'”
And Hope Hicks, Trump’s spokeswoman at the time, even confirmed there would be a press conference.
— Jeremy Diamond (@JDiamond1) August 9, 2016
Why is this a problem?
Well, we don’t really know how Melania ended up getting her green card.
Back in 2000, Melania Knauss, a Slovenian model dating Trump, began petitioning the government for the right to permanently reside in the United States under a program reserved for people with “extraordinary ability.”
Knauss’ credentials included runway shows in Europe, a Camel cigarette billboard ad in Times Square and – in her biggest job at the time – a spot in the swimsuit edition of Sports Illustrated, which featured her on the beach in a string bikini, hugging a six-foot inflatable whale.
She also claimed to be a college graduate.
In March 2001, she was granted a green card in the elite EB-1 program, which was designed for renowned academic researchers, multinational business executives or those in other fields, such as Olympic athletes and Oscar-winning actors, who demonstrated “sustained national and international acclaim.”
“We called it the Einstein visa,” said Bruce Morrison, a former Democratic congressman and chairman of the House subcommittee that wrote the Immigration Act of 1990 defining EB-1.
The year that Knauss – now first lady Melania Trump – got her legal residency, only five people from Slovenia received green cards under the EB-1 program, according to the State Department.
In all, of the more than one million green cards issued in 2001, just 3,376 – or a fraction of one percent – were issued to immigrants with “extraordinary ability,” according to government statistics.
Melania Trump’s ability to secure her green card not only set her on the path to US citizenship, but put her in the position to sponsor the legal residency of her parents, Viktor and Amalija Knavs. The Washington Post reported they obtained their own citizenship.
The biggest question people often have is how did Melania convince immigration authorities that she qualified for the EB-1 program?
Morrison, the former congressman and immigration expert, said that Melania Trump’s resume in 2001 seems “inconsistent” with the requirements of the visa.
To obtain an EB-1 under the extraordinary ability category, an immigrant has to provide evidence of a major award or meet at least three out of 10 criteria. Among them: evidence of commercial successes in the performing arts, evidence of work displayed at artistic exhibitions and evidence of original contributions to a field.
“What did she submit?” asked David Leopold, an immigration lawyer and a past president of the American Immigration Lawyers Association. “There are a lot of questions about how she procured entry into the United States.”
The process of deciding who meets the “extraordinary ability” standard is subjective, said Sarah Pierce, an immigration expert at the Migration Policy Institute, a Washington-based think tank. But it is generally thought that only the top two percent of people in their field would qualify, she said, adding that the “quintessential award you want to put on the application is Nobel Prize.”
The first lady came to the United States from Slovenia in 1996, first briefly on a visitor’s visa and then on work visas, according to Wildes.
Initially, she was not widely known in the highly competitive New York fashion world, according to people in the industry.
“She was never a supermodel, she was a working model – like so many others in New York,” said one person who knew her in the 1990s and requested anonymity to discuss the first lady’s early years in the United States.
In 1998, at age 28, she began dating Trump after meeting him at a party, an association that raised her modeling profile. She started appearing on Page Six and in other celebrity columns on the arm of the real estate developer.
At the time, she was modeling on a work visa for skilled immigrants. Melania Trump received five H1-B visas between October 1996 and 2001, Wildes has said.
Under her husband’s administration, such temporary visas have been harder to get, dropping by more than 50,000 in 2017 compared with the previous year, according to US Citizenship and Immigration Services.
In January 2000, in perhaps her most widely known photo shoot, Melania Trump appeared on the cover of British GQ magazine. She was photographed nude on a fur rug on Donald Trump’s private jet under the headline, “Sex at 30,000 feet. Melania Knauss earns her air miles.”
The accompanying article predicted that the political aspirations of Trump – then making a bid for the Reform Party nomination – could transform his Slovenian girlfriend into the first lady of the United States one day.
“I will put all my effort into it,” she told the magazine, “and I will support my man.”
Melania Trump also claimed to be a college graduate, but that has turned out to be a lie.
Melania claimed to have completed a degree in design and architecture at an unspecified university in Slovenia, her country of birth.
According to Snopes.com:
There is no “University in Slovenia,” nor is there a “University of Slovenia.” The country contains several colleges, including the University of Ljubljana, which other news outlets have reported (without citation) was where Melania obtained her degree. But while the claim that she possesses a degree in Architecture and Design appears on several web sites, these reports lack specific details, such as the year she graduated.
CBS News looked deeper into Melania’s degree after her appearance at the Republican National Convention:
Melania Trump didn’t receive a college degree in design and architecture at the university in Ljubljana, Slovenia, which her biography in the Republican National Convention program claims she had obtained.
CBS News has checked the official public records of the university, and Melania Trump is not listed as having graduated from there with a degree.
So, Melania is a liar, and perhaps lied on her visa application, which deserves a second look, don’t you think??
Regardless, I think we will be waiting for that press conference for a while.